Silent Hill 2 Remake has achieved unprecedented critical success compared to many installments in the series over the years and has received excellent ratings from many international sites, including our review of it. However, despite this success, the game has not been able to surpass the original game’s rating, which is still considered a masterpiece in the world of psychological horror games.
Silent Hill 2 Remake has an average rating of (87 out of 100) based on reviews from about 55 specialized sites. However, despite this success, it has not surpassed the original Silent Hill 2 game, which was released in 2001 and received an average rating of (89 out of 100) based on reviews from 32 sites. It is interesting to note that the third installment of the series, Silent Hill 3, also received the same high rating (89 out of 100).
When comparing the ratings of the original game with the remake, factors such as the number of sites that reviewed each game and the evolution of rating criteria over the years should be considered. However, this comparison raises questions about the remake’s success in delivering an experience that matches or surpasses the original game.
Some may prefer games that offer new and innovative ideas, while others may prefer games that maintain the spirit and essence of the original games. Silent Hill 2 Remake may have focused more on faithfulness to the original at the expense of innovation. Silent Hill 2 was a revolutionary game in its time and had a significant impact on subsequent psychological horror games, making it difficult for any remake to achieve the same level of impact.
Does this mean that the remake is a worse game?
Of course not! This is because Silent Hill 2 Remake is an excellent and wonderful game in every sense of these words, offering an enhanced and impactful psychological horror experience. Even if it did not outperform the original game in ratings, it is still considered a success in its own right.
Main and Sub-Series Ratings of Silent Hill:
- Silent Hill 2 = 89
- Silent Hill 3 = 89
- Silent Hill 2 Remake = 87
- Silent Hill P.T. = 87
- Silent Hill = 86
- Silent Hill 4: The Room = 76
- The Silent Hill Experience = 72
- Silent Hill: Origins = 78
- Silent Hill: Homecoming = 70
- Silent Hill: Shattered Memories = 79
- Silent Hill: Downpour = 64
- Silent Hill HD Collection = 70
- Silent Hill: Book of Memories = 58
- Silent Hill: Ascension = 25
What do you think of Silent Hill 2 Remake? Do you believe it surpassed the original game?